Water: Elementals : Book Review

"Water" by Robin McKinley is a captivating and enchanting novel that offers a refreshing twist on the popular myth of mermaids. It takes place in a world where merfolk coexist with humans, and the story follows the life of Water, a young girl who is part human and part mermaid. McKinley's writing style is exquisite and brings the underwater world to life, immersing readers in a beautiful and vivid aquatic setting.

Water, the protagonist, is a relatable and strong-willed character who embarks on a journey of self-discovery and understanding of her dual nature. McKinley expertly explores themes of identity and acceptance as Water struggles to find her place in both the human and mermaid realms. The author delves into the intricacies of mermaid society, customs, and relationships with humans, creating a rich and immersive world that is both familiar and fantastical.

The attention to detail paid to the underwater world is one of the standout aspects of this book. McKinley's descriptions of the ocean depths and the mermaids' way of life are vivid and evocative, allowing readers to visualise and become part of this enchanting world. The author's beautiful prose perfectly captures the awe and wonder of the ocean, making it an integral part of the narrative.

The plot is well-paced and filled with twists and turns that keep readers engaged until the very end. McKinley seamlessly blends adventure, romance, and mythology, creating a compelling and unique reading experience. The relationships between the characters are well-developed, adding depth and emotional resonance to the story.

Overall, "Water" is a beautifully written and captivating novel that showcases Robin McKinley's ability to create imaginative and engaging worlds. Fans of fantasy and mermaid mythology will be swept away by the enchantment and depth of this tale.

What are readers saying?

Water, a fantasy novel penned by Robin McKinley, has garnered mixed reviews from readers. While some praise McKinley's unique storytelling and beautiful prose, others find the plot and character development lacking.

Many reviewers highlight the enchanting world-building and lyrical writing style as standout aspects of Water. They admire McKinley's ability to create a vivid and immersive setting, allowing readers to easily get lost in the magical realm. The author's attention to detail and skill in weaving together various mythological elements also receive praise.

However, some readers express disappointment with the slow pace and lack of action in the plot. They find the story meandering and lacking clear direction, which can make it difficult to stay engaged. Additionally, a few mention that the overall storyline feels disjointed and fails to fulfill its potential.

Opinions are divided when it comes to the characters. Some appreciate McKinley's ability to create complex and relatable characters, particularly the protagonist who undergoes personal growth and transformation throughout the book. They find her struggles and inner turmoil to be realistic and compelling. However, a few readers feel that the character development is weak, with some side characters appearing underdeveloped and lacking depth.

The romance aspect of the story also receives mixed reactions. While some enjoy the slow-burn and organic progression of the romance, others find it lacking in chemistry and emotional depth. Some express a desire for more exploration and development in this aspect of the story.

WaterBook BookRecommendation MustRead