Water Like a Stone : Book Review

"Water Like a Stone" by Deborah Crombie is an engrossing mystery novel that takes place in the idyllic English countryside. This book is the 11th installment in the popular Duncan Kincaid and Gemma James series and promises to captivate readers with its thrilling plot and well-developed characters.

Set in the charming village of Beck House, the story begins when a young boy and his cousin stumble upon a decomposing body in a local reservoir. This discovery sets off a chain of events that draws Detective Superintendent Duncan Kincaid and Detective Sergeant Gemma James into a twisted web of family secrets, local politics, and buried grudges.

Crombie's writing effortlessly transports readers to the picturesque setting of Beck House, immersing them in its beauty and haunting atmosphere. The author skillfully constructs suspense, leaving readers on the edge of their seats and yearning to uncover the truth behind the perplexing murder. The characters are realistic and relatable, with their own unique motivations and quirks that add depth to the story.

One of the standout qualities of "Water Like a Stone" is how Crombie seamlessly weaves multiple plotlines together. As the investigation unfolds, the mystery deepens, continually surprising and challenging readers' assumptions. The intricate relationships and interconnectedness of the characters make the story even more enthralling, shedding light on the complexities of human nature.

Furthermore, Crombie's meticulous attention to detail brings an added layer of authenticity to the narrative. Whether she is describing the breathtaking English countryside or the intricacies of police procedures, the book feels meticulously researched and grounded in reality. Readers are not only transported into the minds of the characters but also immersed in the heart of the investigation.

What are readers saying?

Deborah Crombie's novel, "Water Like a Stone," has garnered a range of reviews, reflecting the varying opinions of readers. As part of the Duncan Kincaid & Gemma James series, the book combines elements of mystery, suspense, and police procedural. The reception of the book has generally been positive, with readers praising Crombie's writing style and her ability to construct a captivating and intricate plot. The atmospheric descriptions and vivid portrayal of the English countryside during the Christmas season have been particularly well-received.

Many reviewers appreciate the character development in "Water Like a Stone." Duncan Kincaid and Gemma James are regarded as relatable and well-rounded protagonists, and readers commend the depth of their personal lives and relationships. Crombie's exploration of family dynamics and the complexities of human emotions is also lauded.

However, some readers express disappointment with the pacing and structure of the plot. They feel that the story unfolds too slowly at times, and that certain narrative elements become tedious. Additionally, these reviewers note that some intriguing subplots are not given enough attention or resolution.

The ending of the book also evokes varying reactions among readers. While some find it satisfying and well-executed, others believe it to be rushed and lacking closure for certain storylines. This divergence underscores the subjective nature of reader expectations when it comes to concluding a novel.

Overall, "Water Like a Stone" by Deborah Crombie has garnered positive reviews for its engaging writing style and immersive setting. While some reviewers appreciate the character development and intricate plot, others find the pacing and structure lacking. The ending also elicits mixed reactions, emphasizing the different expectations readers have for a satisfying conclusion.

WaterLikeAStone BookRecommendation MysteryNovel