We Can't Eat Prestige: The Women Who Organized Harvard : Book Review

"We Can't Eat Prestige" by John Hoerr offers a compelling and thorough exploration of the decline of the American steel industry, shedding light on the devastating impact it had on workers and their communities. Through extensive interviews with workers, union leaders, and executives, Hoerr provides a nuanced understanding of the economic and political forces that led to the downfall of this once-thriving industry.

The book delves into the shifting dynamics of the steel industry, examining the emergence of foreign competition and technological advancements that rendered traditional steel production methods obsolete. Hoerr skillfully portrays the struggles faced by workers as they grappled with plant closures, layoffs, and the erosion of their livelihoods. He captures their feelings of helplessness and betrayal, while also highlighting their determination to fight for their rights and preserve their way of life.

What sets "We Can't Eat Prestige" apart is Hoerr's ability to analyze the complex political and economic factors at play. He unravels the intricate web of relationships among politicians, union leaders, and company executives, exposing the role that each party played in the industry's demise. This insightful analysis adds depth and complexity to the narrative, elevating it beyond a simple story of economic decline.

Hoerr's writing style is engaging and his research is meticulous. By blending personal stories with historical context, he paints a vivid and compassionate portrait of the impact on workers and their communities. Readers easily empathize with the individuals affected by these changes, as they navigate the challenges brought on by the downfall of the industry.

Overall, "We Can't Eat Prestige" is a thought-provoking and insightful exploration of the decline of the American steel industry. By amplifying the voices of workers and examining the broader political and economic forces at play, John Hoerr offers a comprehensive understanding of this crucial chapter in American history. His book serves as a reminder of the human cost behind economic transformations, and the need for balance between progress and protecting the livelihoods of those affected.

What are readers saying?

The book "We Can't Eat Prestige" by John Hoerr has received a range of reviews. Some readers praised the author's in-depth examination of the decline of the steel industry in America, commending the extensive interviews with steelworkers and the insider's perspective provided. They found the book valuable for its analysis of the complex economic and political factors that contributed to the industry's downfall, particularly in cities like Pittsburgh. These reviewers believed that it offered a valuable resource for understanding the effects of deindustrialization on American workers.

However, not all readers were fully satisfied with the book. Some felt that it lacked a strong narrative and failed to engage their interest effectively. They found Hoerr's writing style to be dry and academic, which made it difficult for them to fully immerse themselves in the subject matter. These readers felt that the author could have presented his analysis in a more accessible and compelling manner.

Furthermore, some reviewers criticized Hoerr for his biased portrayal of the steel industry and its workers. They believed that the book relied too heavily on personal anecdotes and did not offer a comprehensive analysis of the broader economic factors at play in the industry's decline.

Despite these mixed reviews, "We Can't Eat Prestige" was praised for shedding light on an important aspect of American history. Several readers found it to be an eye-opening exploration of the impact of deindustrialization on communities and individuals.

In conclusion, the reviews for "We Can't Eat Prestige" by John Hoerr are varied. While some readers valued the author's thorough research and personal interviews, others felt that the book lacked narrative cohesiveness and engaging writing. Nonetheless, it still provides valuable insights into the decline of the steel industry and its effects on American workers.

WeCantEatPrestige FoodForThought BreakingSocietalNorms