What about Annie? : Book Review

"What About Annie?" by Claudia Mills is an incredibly heartwarming and thought-provoking middle-grade novel that dives into the themes of friendship, understanding, and the power of empathy. It tells the story of Rebecca, a student who discovers a new classmate named Annie who has a disability. Through Rebecca's journey of learning about Annie's condition, the reader is taken on a journey of self-discovery and understanding.

Mills showcases remarkable skill in portraying the complex emotions and challenges faced by both Rebecca and Annie. Rebecca's initial struggle to comprehend Annie's disability and her gradual realization that Annie is just like any other person is both authentic and relatable. This allows readers to deeply reflect on the importance of compassion and inclusion.

The book skillfully tackles sensitive topics with grace and sensitivity, emphasizing the significance of treating everyone with kindness and respect. Mills's writing style actively engages young readers, allowing them to easily connect with the story. The growing friendship between Rebecca and Annie is heartwarming, and readers will find themselves rooting for these two characters to overcome obstacles together.

"What About Annie?" also sheds light on the value of communication and breaking down stereotypes. Rebecca's conversations with her family and friends about Annie's disability serve as an educational tool, not only for Rebecca but also for the readers, in dispelling misconceptions surrounding disabilities. This aspect of the story promotes a more inclusive mindset among young readers.

In conclusion, "What About Annie?" is a touching and memorable middle-grade novel that encourages empathy, understanding, and acceptance. Claudia Mills expertly tackles the complexities of friendship and disability, leaving readers with a deeper appreciation for the power of inclusivity. This book is a must-read for young readers seeking to expand their horizons and learn the beauty of embracing differences.

What are readers saying?

"What about Annie?" is a book authored by Claudia Mills, which has sparked varying opinions among readers. The story revolves around Annie, a 10-year-old girl grappling with her weight and body image, while also navigating through friendship and family dynamics.

Certain reviewers commended Mills for approaching significant and relatable topics with sensitivity. They appreciated the book's exploration of body positivity and self-acceptance, as Annie's journey was portrayed with empathy and authenticity. The strong character development particularly stood out, as Annie's insecurities and personal growth were thoughtfully depicted. The emphasis on the importance of friendship and family relationships resonated with many readers as well.

On the other hand, some reviewers expressed disappointment with certain aspects of the book. They felt that the writing style was overly simplistic, targeting a younger audience and making it challenging for them to fully engage with the story. The resolution of Annie's struggles was also criticized for being too convenient and lacking a deeper exploration of the underlying issues.

A few readers also commented on the lack of diversity within the book, noting that the experiences and backgrounds of the characters were not adequately represented, which hindered their connection to the story. Some reviewers also found certain plot points to be predictable and desired a higher level of complexity in the narrative.

Overall, "What about Annie?" by Claudia Mills evokes a range of reactions from readers. While some appreciate the book's sensitive portrayal of body image and strong character development, others feel it lacks depth and diversity. Ultimately, readers seeking a book that addresses important themes such as self-acceptance and friendship may find value in this story, while those craving more complexity or diversity may be left wanting.

AnnieBook WhatAboutAnnie BookRecommendations