What to Look for in a Classroom: ...and Other Essays : Book Review

"What to Look for in a Classroom" by Alfie Kohn offers a refreshing perspective on effective education by challenging traditional practices. Kohn emphasizes that a nurturing and engaging environment, rather than strict adherence to test scores and curriculum standards, is key to a successful classroom. Backed by extensive research and real-life examples, Kohn provides practical advice for teachers, parents, and administrators on promoting creativity, critical thinking, and intrinsic motivation among students.

One crucial aspect discussed in the book is the significance of autonomy and choice in education. Kohn suggests that when students have a say in their learning process, they become more invested and motivated. He cites numerous examples where teachers empower their students to make decisions about assignments, assessments, and even topics of study, leading to increased enthusiasm and engagement.

Another important concept brought forth by Kohn is the need to replace reward and punishment systems in classrooms. He argues that relying on external motivators, such as grades and rewards, hinders students' natural love for learning and creativity. Instead, Kohn suggests focusing on intrinsic motivation by creating purpose, relevance, and joy within the classroom. Practical suggestions, such as using feedback rather than grades to assess progress, are provided to help implement this approach.

Furthermore, the book challenges the idea of competition among students. Kohn asserts that fostering a collaborative and supportive environment promotes teamwork and growth. He advocates for cooperative learning strategies that encourage students to work together and celebrate each other's successes.

In summary, "What to Look for in a Classroom" is a thought-provoking book that challenges conventional educational practices. Kohn's insights and recommendations provide a roadmap for creating an environment where students thrive, feel valued, and develop a genuine love for learning. This book is a valuable resource for educators, parents, and anyone interested in revolutionizing the educational experience for children.

What are readers saying?

The book "What to Look for in a Classroom" by Alfie Kohn has received a range of reviews, with some readers finding it insightful and thought-provoking, while others found it lacking in practicality and being too idealistic.

Many reviewers found value in Kohn's emphasis on nurturing intrinsic motivation in students and creating a positive learning environment. They saw the book as a valuable resource for educators, offering innovative ideas for managing classrooms and promoting student engagement. The emphasis on cooperative learning and collaborative problem-solving was especially well-received by these readers.

However, there were some criticisms of the book, with reviewers arguing that it was overly theoretical and lacking in practical suggestions for implementation. They felt that Kohn's ideas were idealistic and did not easily translate to real-world classrooms. These readers were seeking more concrete strategies and specific examples to apply to their teaching practice.

A common theme among negative reviews was the perception that Kohn's perspective was biased against traditional teaching methods and standardized testing. These readers felt that the book failed to acknowledge the importance of aspects such as accountability and objective assessments in education.

Despite these criticisms, many readers still found value in Kohn's arguments and appreciated the thought-provoking nature of the book. They felt that it challenged their preconceived notions about education and encouraged them to reflect on their teaching practices.

classroomtips teachingresources educationinsights