What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam & Modernity in the Middle East : Book Review

"What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam & Modernity in the Middle East" by Bernard Lewis is a thought-provoking book that examines the difficulties encountered by the Muslim world in adapting to modernity. With his expertise in Middle Eastern history, Lewis explores the historical, cultural, and political factors that have shaped the current situation in the Middle East.

Lewis begins by acknowledging the rich history of Islamic civilization, highlighting its achievements in areas such as science, philosophy, and governance. However, he argues that the Muslim world failed to keep pace with the transformative changes that occurred in Europe during the Renaissance, Enlightenment, and Industrial Revolution. This divergence, Lewis asserts, lies at the heart of the clash between Islam and modernity.

The author emphasizes significant historical events, including the decline of the Ottoman Empire and the subsequent colonization of Arab lands by Western powers. Lewis suggests that these events bred a deep sense of humiliation and resentment within the Muslim world, ultimately catalyzing the rise of religious fundamentalism as a response to modernity. He delves into the different forms of fundamentalism that have emerged, including the growth of radical ideologies like Islamism.

In addition, Lewis examines the role of religion in shaping governance and society in the Middle East. He argues that the absence of a clear separation between religion and state, coupled with a lack of tradition in secular governance, has hindered progress and fostered an atmosphere of authoritarianism and intolerance. Consequently, this has impeded the development of democratic institutions and stifled individual freedoms.

Lewis presents a comprehensive analysis, shedding light on the historical, cultural, and political factors contributing to the clash between Islam and modernity in the Middle East. "What Went Wrong?" provides valuable insights for those seeking a deeper understanding of the challenges faced by the region and the broader Muslim world as they grapple with the forces of globalization and modernization.

What are readers saying?

"What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam & Modernity in the Middle East" by Bernard Lewis is a thought-provoking book that explores the intricate relationship between Islam and modernization in the Middle East. Reviews for this book offer a diverse range of opinions, blending both praise and criticism.

Many reviewers appreciate Lewis's extensive knowledge and expertise on the subject, applauding his ability to provide historical context and in-depth analysis. They find his arguments compelling as he delves into the roots of the Middle East's struggle with modernity, including factors such as colonialism, political systems, and cultural traditions. Readers admire Lewis for his balanced approach, where he neither entirely blames Islam nor absolves it of all responsibility, but rather examines the nuanced dynamics at play.

Some reviewers appreciate Lewis's talent for presenting complex ideas in a clear and accessible manner, making it suitable for both experts and general readers. They find his writing engaging, which helps them grasp the intricacies of the topic. Lewis further enriches readers' understanding by including case studies and anecdotes, allowing them to connect theoretical concepts with real-world examples.

However, some reviewers express concerns about Lewis's perspective and accuse him of bias or selectively choosing evidence to support his arguments. They argue that his analysis lacks depth and fails to consider the diversity within the Middle East, with a focus solely on negative aspects. In addition, a few critics criticize Lewis for not providing concrete solutions or a path forward to address the challenges posed by the clash between Islam and modernity.

Overall, "What Went Wrong? The Clash Between Islam & Modernity in the Middle East" garners praise for its comprehensive analysis and insightful exploration of a complex subject. It is commended for its accessibility and ability to stimulate meaningful discussions. However, it also faces criticism for potential bias and lack of depth in certain aspects. Despite these criticisms, the book remains highly regarded for its valuable contribution to the understanding of the Middle East's struggle with modernity.

WhatWentWrong IslamAndModernity MiddleEastConflict