When She Was Good : Book Review

"When She Was Good" by Norma Fox Mazer is an incredibly captivating coming-of-age novel that follows the turbulent life of Em, a troubled teenage girl trying to navigate her identity and past. The story is set against the backdrop of 1970s New York City and delves into themes such as family, love, and self-discovery. Mazer's writing is both descriptive and emotionally charged, transporting readers to the gritty streets of the city during a tumultuous time.

One of the strengths of the novel lies in Mazer's ability to handle difficult subject matter with sensitivity and grace. She explores the complexities of family dynamics, emphasizing the lasting impact of past trauma on present relationships. The portrayal of sexual assault is also handled delicately, shedding light on its lingering effects and the challenging path to healing.

The pacing of the book is well-balanced, maintaining reader engagement and investment in Em's journey. The plot unfolds naturally, gradually revealing new layers of the protagonist's past and inner struggles. As the story progresses, readers are taken on an emotional rollercoaster, experiencing both heartache and hope alongside Em.

Mazer's attention to detail and vivid imagery bring the story to life, making it easy to visualize and empathize with the characters. Em's voice is authentic and raw, allowing readers to genuinely connect with her struggles and emotions.

Overall, "When She Was Good" is a poignant and thought-provoking novel that explores the complexities of adolescence and the search for identity. Norma Fox Mazer's compelling storytelling and well-developed characters make this book a must-read for fans of coming-of-age stories and contemporary young adult fiction.

What are readers saying?

The novel "When She Was Good" by Norma Fox Mazer has garnered a range of responses from readers. While some commend the book for its realistic depiction of teenage challenges and its ability to emotionally engage readers, others criticize the underdeveloped characters and shallow plot.

Positive reviews highlight the book's capacity to capture the complexities of teenage life. Many readers find the protagonist's journey of self-discovery relatable and commend the author for effectively portraying the raw emotions and obstacles faced by teenagers. The story is praised for its exploration of family dynamics and the difficulties teenagers encounter when navigating relationships.

Conversely, some readers express disappointment with the book. They feel that the characters are poorly developed, making it difficult to form a deep connection with them. The protagonist is sometimes considered unlikable and lacking in depth, resulting in a challenge for readers to invest in her story. The plot is also criticized for being predictable and lacking originality, with some reviewers feeling that it fails to offer anything new or thought-provoking.

In conclusion, opinions on "When She Was Good" by Norma Fox Mazer are divided. While some readers appreciate its realistic portrayal of teenage struggles and emotional depth, others believe the characters are underdeveloped and the plot lacks substance. It is important to consider that individual reading experiences and personal preferences can greatly influence one's perception of a book.