When We Were Orphans : Book Review

"When We Were Orphans" by Kazuo Ishiguro is an enthralling historical novel that transports readers to the early 1900s. The story centers around Christopher Banks, a renowned detective in London, as he embarks on a personal journey to uncover the truth behind his parents' disappearance in Shanghai years ago. Ishiguro's vivid and atmospheric prose weaves together themes of memory, identity, and the blurred boundaries between reality and imagination.

Ishiguro's attention to detail is evident as he masterfully paints the backdrop of pre-war London and the exotic landscape of Shanghai. By immersing readers in these richly drawn settings, he effectively brings to life the social and political tensions of the time, particularly in the context of the Sino-Japanese War. The setting becomes more than just a backdrop, shaping the lives and motivations of the characters.

The protagonist, Christopher Banks, is a complex and introspective character who becomes consumed by his quest for truth. As he unravels the layers of his own memories, he must confront the fallibility of recollection and the profound impact it can have on one's sense of self. Ishiguro delves deep into the human psyche, exploring themes of guilt, the unreliable nature of memory, and the yearning for closure and connection.

The plot is intricately constructed, seamlessly moving between Christopher's childhood in Shanghai and his adult life in London. With a measured pace, Ishiguro gradually reveals the truth behind his parents' disappearance, skillfully building tension and suspense that keeps readers engaged and guessing until the final pages.

Overall, "When We Were Orphans" is a beautifully written and thought-provoking novel that blends elements of mystery, historical fiction, and psychological exploration. Ishiguro's lyrical prose and nuanced characterization create an immersive reading experience that will captivate both fans of his previous works and new readers.

What are readers saying?

Opinions on Kazuo Ishiguro's novel "When We Were Orphans" have been divided among readers on Goodreads. While some reviewers praised the book's beautiful writing style and engaging narrative, others found it slow-paced and difficult to connect with. The protagonist, Christopher Banks, was considered by some to be a complex and interesting character, while others struggled to form a connection with him. The exploration of themes such as memory, identity, and childhood trauma was appreciated by some readers, but others felt that the narrative became disjointed and confusing at times.

One aspect of the book that received mixed reactions was the inclusion of historical context. Some readers found the detailed portrayal of Shanghai during the Japanese occupation to be fascinating, and appreciated the author's thorough research. They felt that the historical backdrop added depth and enriched the story. However, there were also readers who felt that the heavy reliance on historical context made the novel inaccessible to those without prior knowledge of the period. They felt that it overshadowed the development of the characters and made it challenging to fully engage with the story.

The atmospheric descriptions of Shanghai were particularly praised by those who enjoyed the book. The city itself became a character in the story and added to the overall ambiance of the narrative. The mystery element of the plot was also found intriguing, as the truth gradually unraveled throughout the book.

However, there were readers who found the novel to be overly ponderous and lacking a strong plot. They felt that the story was slow-paced and struggled to connect with Christopher Banks as a protagonist. Some reviewers found the narrative to be disjointed and confusing at times, making it difficult to follow the story. Additionally, the ending of the novel was perceived as abrupt and unsatisfying by some readers.

In summary, opinions on "When We Were Orphans" by Kazuo Ishiguro vary among readers. While some appreciated the beautiful prose and exploration of complex themes, others found the book to be slow-paced and challenging to connect with. The historical context of the novel also received mixed reactions, with some readers enjoying the depth it added to the story while others felt it hindered their overall enjoyment. The atmospheric descriptions and the gradual unraveling of the mystery were aspects that attracted positive feedback from readers.

WhenWeWereOrphans KazuoIshiguro BooksAreMagic