Where Mathematics Come From: How the Embodied Mind Brings Mathematics into Being : Book Review

"Where Mathematics Come From" offers a fascinating exploration into the deep roots and conceptual foundations of mathematics, presented by acclaimed cognitive scientist George Lakoff. In this thought-provoking book, Lakoff unveils the interconnectedness between mathematics, philosophy, and the human mind, providing readers with a fresh perspective on how mathematical concepts emerge and shape our understanding of the world.

By drawing on research from cognitive science, linguistics, and mathematics, Lakoff challenges the conventional notion that mathematics is an abstract system detached from human experience. Instead, he argues that mathematical concepts are deeply rooted in the embodied experiences of our physical bodies and our interactions with the world. This perspective emphasizes that mathematics is more than just a collection of rules and formulas—it is a living and evolving set of principles that arise from our innate cognitive abilities.

One of the strengths of Lakoff's writing is his ability to present complex ideas and theories in a clear and accessible manner, making them understandable to both experts and lay readers. Through numerous examples and case studies, ranging from basic arithmetic to advanced mathematical concepts, he illustrates the connections between everyday experiences and the abstract world of mathematics. This approach allows readers to see mathematics as a natural extension of human thought, rather than something foreign or inaccessible.

Furthermore, Lakoff delves into the role of metaphor in shaping our understanding of mathematical concepts. He suggests that metaphors are not merely linguistic tools, but fundamental cognitive mechanisms that structure our comprehension of mathematics. This thought-provoking insight challenges readers to reassess their preconceived notions about math and encourages them to embrace a more holistic and embodied approach to the subject.

In conclusion, "Where Mathematics Come From" is a thought-provoking and enlightening exploration of the cognitive origins of mathematics. George Lakoff's expertise, clear writing style, and engaging examples make this book a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the foundations of mathematics and the intricate connections between language, cognition, and the human mind.

What are readers saying?

"Where Mathematics Come From" by George Lakoff has garnered a variety of reviews, reflecting different perspectives on the book's philosophical foundations of mathematics. While some readers highly commend its unique viewpoint, others find it complex and hard to follow.

Many reviewers appreciate Lakoff's examination of the embodied nature of mathematical concepts, considering his arguments regarding the correlation between mathematical reasoning and our physical experiences as enlightening and thought-provoking. These individuals perceive the book as a fascinating and groundbreaking exploration of the cognitive basis of mathematics.

Conversely, certain reviewers struggle with Lakoff's writing style and the abstract concepts he delves into, finding the book dense and challenging to comprehend fully. They may feel that a more substantial background in mathematics or cognitive science would be necessary to fully appreciate and understand the content.

Another point of contention among reviewers is the book's level of accessibility. While some regard it as an excellent introduction to the philosophy of mathematics, others believe it presupposes a significant amount of prior knowledge in both mathematics and cognitive science. This divergence of opinion suggests that readers with different backgrounds may encounter varying levels of difficulty with the material.

Several reviewers also express disappointment with the absence of concrete mathematical examples and the heavy emphasis on theory, yearning for more practical illustrations to solidify their understanding of the discussed concepts.

MathematicsExplained OriginOfMath MathConnection