Who Broke Lincoln's Thumb? : Book Review

"Who Broke Lincoln's Thumb?" by Ron Roy is an exciting and suspenseful children's mystery book that is part of the popular "A to Z Mysteries" series. In this installment, Dink, Josh, and Ruth Rose, the young protagonists, find themselves immersed in a fascinating case involving stolen artifacts from the town's new history museum. When the thumb of a statue of Abraham Lincoln is mysteriously broken off, the trio embarks on a mission to unveil the culprit.

The characters in "Who Broke Lincoln's Thumb?" are well-developed and relatable, making it easy for young readers to connect with them. Dink, Josh, and Ruth Rose make a likeable team, each bringing their unique skills to the investigation. Their friendship and teamwork are evident as they work together to solve the mystery and catch the thief. Children will enjoy following their journey and trying to solve the puzzle alongside them.

An outstanding aspect of this book is its educational value. Ron Roy seamlessly incorporates a rich historical backdrop into the engaging storyline, providing fascinating facts about Abraham Lincoln and the significance of his thumb statue. This educational aspect adds depth to the story, making it both entertaining and informative for young readers.

Ron Roy's writing style is straightforward and accessible, making the book suitable for independent reading or read-aloud sessions. The chapters are short, and the pacing is well-balanced, ensuring that young readers remain engrossed throughout. The inclusion of illustrations by John Steven Gurney enhances the visual appeal of the book and brings the story to life.

Overall, "Who Broke Lincoln's Thumb?" is an engaging and well-crafted mystery book that will captivate children while teaching them about history. Ron Roy's storytelling abilities and the relatable characters make this book an enjoyable reading experience for kids who love solving mysteries.

What are readers saying?

"Who Broke Lincoln's Thumb?" written by Ron Roy has received a range of reviews from readers. The general consensus suggests that it is a captivating mystery book aimed at children, although it may lack in-depth storytelling and character development.

Some readers found the book engaging and thrilling, praising Ron Roy's writing style for its ability to capture the attention of young readers. The mystery plot received particular commendation, with readers enjoying the puzzles and clues that were presented throughout the story. Furthermore, the relatable characters and humor were highlighted as positive elements that made the book an enjoyable read.

However, some readers felt that the book fell short in certain aspects. There were comments about the story being predictable and lacking surprises, which could potentially make it less engaging for older or more experienced readers. Additionally, concerns were raised regarding the lack of depth in the characters, with some finding them to be one-dimensional and underdeveloped.

A few readers also criticized the pacing and length of the book. Some felt that it was too short and rushed, which limited the opportunity to fully explore the mystery or develop the characters. Consequently, these issues led to a sense of dissatisfaction with the overall reading experience.

Despite the mixed reviews, the book seems to be generally well-received by its intended audience of young readers. "Who Broke Lincoln's Thumb?" offers an enjoyable and entertaining mystery, complete with relatable characters and an intriguing plot. However, readers seeking more depth or those with more experience may find the book lacking in certain aspects, such as the predictability of the story and the underdeveloped characters.

WhoBrokeLincolnsThumb MysteryBook CrimeNovel