Who Defended The Country?: A New Democracy Forum on Authoritarian versus Democratic Approaches to National Defense on 9/11 : Book Review

"Who Defended the Country?" by Elaine Scarry is a captivating and thought-provoking book that dives deep into the concept of national defense. Scarry presents a compelling argument that challenges traditional notions of protection and security, examining the historical and philosophical aspects of defense and its impact on society.

One of the book's notable strengths is Scarry's ability to draw from a wide range of sources, seamlessly incorporating ideas from influential thinkers like Immanuel Kant and Simone Weil. By combining historical analysis with philosophical insights, she offers readers a comprehensive and interdisciplinary exploration of defense, enriching their understanding of the subject.

Scarry raises important questions about the relationship between the military and civilian life, shedding light on how the prioritization of defense can overshadow other crucial sectors like education and healthcare. This emphasis on defense often leads to a disproportionate allocation of resources, potentially neglecting other vital aspects of a nation's well-being.

The author's writing style is another highlight of the book. Scarry presents complex ideas in a clear and accessible manner, ensuring that readers from various backgrounds can engage with the content. This makes "Who Defended the Country?" a valuable resource for anyone interested in contemplating the implications of defense in modern society.

Overall, "Who Defended the Country?" is an enlightening and thought-provoking book that challenges conventional beliefs about defense. Scarry's extensive research and insightful analysis encourage readers to critically examine the role of the military and its impact on society. With its engaging writing style and interdisciplinary approach, this book makes an important contribution to the discourse surrounding national defense and its wider implications.

What are readers saying?

"Who Defended the Country" by Elaine Scarry has received varying feedback from readers, with some praising the author's insightful analysis and engaging writing style, while others found the book to be dense and difficult to follow.

A number of reviewers appreciated Scarry's in-depth exploration of the concept of defense and its societal implications. They commended the book for its thorough research and intellectual stimulation, as Scarry provided thought-provoking perspectives on military power and national security. The integration of theory with real-world examples was also lauded, as it made the book relatable and relevant.

However, there were readers who found "Who Defended the Country" overly complicated and convoluted. They struggled to grasp the author's arguments, partly due to the inclusion of complex theoretical concepts. Some reviewers also found the writing style dry and academic, making it challenging to maintain interest in the subject matter.

Despite the differing opinions on the book's accessibility, many readers agreed that Scarry presented a unique perspective on defense and raised important questions about its impact on individuals and society. The author's critical examination of the relationship between military power and democracy resonated with readers and sparked insightful discussions.

Reviewers also remarked on Scarry's thorough analysis of case studies, which further enriched the book's content. By exploring historical events and their underlying defense mechanisms, Scarry encouraged readers to think critically about the role of defense in shaping political systems and societal norms.

WhoDefendedTheCountry BookRecommendation MilitaryHistory