Why Nothing Works: The Anthropology of Daily Life : Book Review

Marvin Harris' "Why Nothing Works: The Anthropology of Daily Life" is a captivating exploration of why certain systems and institutions fail to achieve their intended goals. Harris, a renowned anthropologist, delves into various aspects of human culture, such as education, politics, healthcare, and religion, to analyze the underlying factors that contribute to their inefficiencies. He presents a compelling argument that cultural materialism is the key to understanding these failures.

Harris skillfully applies anthropological theory to real-world examples throughout the book, demonstrating his expertise in the field. He explores how cultural beliefs, values, and practices shape our institutions, highlighting how changes in these cultural elements can result in systemic dysfunction. Rather than blaming individuals, Harris argues that it is the underlying cultural forces that perpetuate ineffective approaches and hinder social programs and policies from succeeding.

One of the strengths of Harris' work is his ability to present complex ideas in a clear and accessible manner. He avoids jargon and uses concise language, making it easy for both experts and casual readers to comprehend his arguments. Additionally, Harris supports his claims with thorough research and abundant evidence, including case studies and historical data, which bolsters the credibility of his assertions.

Critics of the book argue that Harris' emphasis on cultural materialism overlooks other significant factors, such as economic interests, power dynamics, and historical contexts, when analyzing societal failures. However, even if readers do not fully agree with all of Harris' conclusions, his perspective undeniably provokes thought and provides valuable insights into the dysfunctional aspects of society.

In conclusion, "Why Nothing Works" offers a compelling analysis of the deficiencies in various societal institutions, using anthropological theory as its foundation. Marvin Harris provides readers with a unique perspective on the cultural forces that contribute to systemic dysfunction. Whether you have an interest in anthropology, sociology, or social policy, this book offers valuable insights into the factors that undermine the effectiveness of our daily life systems.

What are readers saying?

The book "Why Nothing Works: The Anthropology of Daily Life" by Marvin Harris has received a mix of reviews, with some readers appreciating the author's perspective and informative content, while others criticize its complexity and lack of engaging writing style.

Some reviewers admire Marvin Harris for his comprehensive exploration of societal issues such as poverty, crime, and education. They appreciate his anthropological approach and his effort to uncover the underlying causes of these problems. Many readers find his analysis thought-provoking and value the extensive research that has gone into the book. They believe that Harris offers valuable insights into the reasons why certain social and economic systems fail.

However, other readers find the book to be excessively dense and difficult to navigate. They argue that Harris's use of highly technical language and complex concepts hinders the accessibility of his ideas. Some reviewers also lament the absence of engaging storytelling or relatable examples, making it difficult to stay interested throughout the book. Consequently, they believe that the book fails to effectively communicate its ideas to a general audience.

In addition, a few reviewers express disappointment with the outdated nature of some of Harris's arguments. They argue that societal issues have evolved since the book's publication and that it would benefit from updated research or a more contemporary perspective. Some readers also note that the book lacks coherence and structure, making it challenging to follow Harris's arguments from start to finish.

In conclusion, "Why Nothing Works: The Anthropology of Daily Life" by Marvin Harris provides a complex and insightful analysis of societal issues. While some readers appreciate the extensive research and thought-provoking ideas presented, others find the book overly complex and lacking in an engaging writing style. It may be more suitable for readers with a specific interest in anthropology and sociology, rather than a general audience seeking a more accessible examination of societal problems.

WhyNothingWorks BookRecommendation NonFiction