Writing the Qualitative Dissertation: Understanding by Doing : Book Review

"Writing the Qualitative Dissertation" written by Judith M. Meloy is a comprehensive and invaluable guide for graduate students who are about to embark on the journey of writing a qualitative dissertation. Meloy offers valuable tips and insights to help students navigate the complex process of conducting qualitative research and presenting it in a doctoral dissertation.

The book covers every stage of the dissertation process, starting from selecting a topic and designing the study to analyzing the data and presenting the findings. Meloy highlights the importance of thoughtful planning and organization in qualitative research and provides guidance on creating a solid research proposal, including research questions and potential methods for data collection. She also discusses various qualitative research methods, such as interviews, observations, and document analysis, and provides an in-depth analysis of their strengths and limitations. This empowers readers to make informed decisions about which methods are most suitable for their own research.

One of the strengths of "Writing the Qualitative Dissertation" is Meloy's emphasis on writing itself. The author offers practical strategies for writing effectively, developing a coherent argument, and structuring chapters in a meaningful way. She provides numerous examples and writing exercises to help students improve their writing skills. Meloy's recognition of writing as a tool for refining ideas is particularly beneficial for those who are new to qualitative research.

In addition to addressing the writing process, the book also tackles common challenges faced by qualitative researchers, such as ethical considerations, establishing credibility, and researcher bias. Meloy offers practical advice and tips for overcoming these challenges, equipping readers with the necessary tools and confidence to navigate potential pitfalls.

Overall, "Writing the Qualitative Dissertation" serves as an essential resource for graduate students undertaking qualitative research. It provides a comprehensive overview of the entire research process, with a strong focus on effective writing and research design. Meloy's practical advice and examples make complex concepts more accessible, enabling students to approach their research with confidence and produce a high-quality qualitative dissertation.

What are readers saying?

The book "Writing the Qualitative Dissertation" by Judith M. Meloy has generally received positive reviews from readers. Geared towards graduate students and researchers beginning the process of writing a qualitative dissertation, the book offers clear instructions and step-by-step guidance, which many reviewers appreciate. This practical approach has proven helpful for readers in terms of organizing and planning their own dissertations.

The accessibility and reader-friendly language of the book are commended by reviewers. Meloy effectively breaks down complex concepts and methodologies into simpler terms, making it easier for beginners to grasp the content. Additionally, the engaging and approachable writing style of the author keeps readers motivated throughout the dissertation journey.

Reviewers particularly value the real-life examples and case studies included in the book. These examples help readers understand how to apply the discussed concepts and techniques. The practicality of these examples is mentioned, as they bridge the gap between theory and real-world application.

Ethical considerations in qualitative research receive significant attention in the book, a feature that reviewers appreciate. Meloy dedicates a section to discussing ethical issues and provides guidance on how to address them within the dissertation. This section is praised for its relevance and importance in conducting ethical research.

Despite the book receiving mostly positive feedback, there is a minority of reviewers who express disappointment with the book's length and depth. They feel that some topics are not explored in enough detail, leaving them wanting more information. However, it is important to acknowledge that the majority of readers consider the book comprehensive enough for their needs.

QualitativeDissertation WritingTips ResearchJourney